Host Engineering Forum
General Category => Do-more CPUs and Do-more Designer Software => Topic started by: Mike Nash on April 22, 2015, 06:45:52 PM
-
I see Automation Direct is now offering a Facts Engineering product that looks to be a direct competitor for the DL-205 series. And here I've been waiting (somewhat impatiently) for the latest Host offering.
I'm guessing this might be a toe-stepping area so maybe no one wants to discuss this. But if you do, I'm all ears as to where this is headed.
I haven't even looked at the P2 software yet so I have no opinions really. I am reluctant to be the guinea pig though (I waited two years to "Do-more". ;) )
-
Yeah, but it's the same programming environment as the P3K, so for me at least......no.
-
Yeah, but it's the same programming environment as the P3K, so for me at least......no.
I have to agree did one project with the P3K. Never did feel right and once you assigned a tag name forget finding the I/O Address. Then gave up waiting on the promised motion control module.
-
Smaller, cheaper version of the P3K. If you liked the P3K, I'm sure you'll love P2K. I wish them well.
Of course we are moving full speed ahead on our next platform as well. If you like Do-more on DL205, you're going to love it on the new hardware. Wish I could say more.
-
The P2K is an iffy sale to me too. Don't get me wrong, the thing looks amazing, the LCD screens on the analog modules are a great idea(hint, hint, wink, wink), but when it comes down to it, the system limitations point me else where.
1.) 240 I/O points and that's it. No native I/O expansion.
2.) Connections, you buy the card and then you have to buy a separate connector? I'm not cheap, but that's a design nightmare. Real easy to order the wrong connector or not one at all and then start building a project and see, oh darn I'm held up for a 7 buck connector.
3.) Do-More can drop into an existing system, and use the stock of DL205 cards I have as spares.
Don't get me wrong, after looking over the offerings, the P2k looks to be a good value for the cost. For some new designs, I can actually see myself using it. Our Wire Drawing units would fit the bill. 64 I/O with analog. But after switching from a D250-2 to a Do-More, the ease of a major upgrade by just dropping in a new CPU far outweighs what the P2k can give me.
I also held off our system upgrades for a year just to use the Do-More after using the simulator and I can't wait to see the newest offering.
I don't see this as much as toe stepping as product evolution. The DL series is a good product but it shows it's age. The Do-More is it's fresher, younger sibling, but in the end there is only so much you can do with the base platform.